Choosing Your Hot Water System: Comparing Gas, Electric, and On-Demand

Choosing Your Hot Water System: Gas, Electric, and On-Demand


Hot water is something we use every day in our homes, whether it’s for showering, washing dishes, or doing laundry. So, it’s really important to have a reliable hot water. Today, we're going to explore the three main types of hot water tanks - gas, electric, and on-demand - to help you figure out which one might be the best fit for your home.


A Look Into Gas Water Heaters


Gas water heaters use natural gas to heat water. Imagine having a small fire under a big pot of water. The fire heats the pot and the water inside it gets warm. That's kind of how a gas water heater works, but in a much safer and controlled way.


What’s cool about them?: Gas water heaters can heat water pretty fast, and they can still work even when there’s no electricity. This is great for times when there’s a power outage.


Things to think about: They need a gas source, must be a vented to the outside,which must be done by a Licensed Gas Fitter as well as a plumber to hook the tank up to your household water system


Diving Into Electric Water Heaters


Electric water heaters use electricity to heat up water. Think of a big electric kettle. You plug it in, and an element inside heats up and makes the water hot.


What’s cool about them?: They’re easier to install than gas heaters, don’t need a vent or chimney and can be installed by a plumber. They can fit in more places around the home.


Things to think about: They might take a bit longer to heat water compared to gas. Also, if there’s a power outage, they won’t work. The cost of running them depends on the price of electricity where you live and how much water you use.


Getting to Know On-Demand Water Heaters


On-demand water heaters, also known as tankless water heaters, are pretty nifty because they heat water only when you need it. Imagine turning on a magic tap that instantly gives you hot water without having to wait. they can be powered by either electricity or gas.


What’s cool about them?: They can save you money over time because you’re only heating water when you need it, not storing hot water that you might not use. They’re also quite small and don’t take up much space.


Things to think about: The upfront cost can be higher than traditional gas or electric hot water tanks. Also, they need to be sized  appropriately to ensure that if everyone in the house wants to take a shower at the same time, the heater can keep up. .If you choose a gas on demand system, you need the gas piping and gas venting done for a Licensed Gas Fitter and the water hook up done by a plumber


How Do You Pick the Right One?


Choosing the right hot water system depends on a few things:


- Your home: This includes how much space you have and whether you can vent a gas heater outside

- Your needs: Think about how much hot water you use. A big family might have different needs than someone living alone.

- Your budget: Not just the upfront cost, but also how much it might cost to run the heater over time.

- annual maintenance


It's a good idea to talk to a professional who can help you think through these things and pick the best option for your home.


Let's Make Warm Memories Together!


We know that choosing the right hot water system can be a big decision. But you don’t have to make it alone. Whether you’re thinking about gas, electric, or on-demand, we’re here to help you find the perfect fit for your cozy home. At Call the Plumbing Doctor, we believe in making homes comfortable and happy places to be. We have a licensed gas fitter on staff so we can assist you with whatever system you feel best suits you and your family.


Ready to dive into warm waters? Give us a call at 1-800-814-7014 or visit our website. Let’s make sure every bath, shower, and wash is a warm and wonderful experience for you and your family.


Choosing a hot water system doesn’t have to be a daunting task. With the right information and a bit of guidance, you can find the one that keeps your home running smoothly. Let’s get started together!

Share This Blog

White boiler system with gas line, expansion tank, and distribution box on a white wall.
December 17, 2025
Think you know winter plumbing? We debunk common cold-weather myths and share the real facts for keeping your pipes and sewers safe this season.
Man in overalls giving a thumbs-up next to a water softener in a utility room.
December 9, 2025
Discover top water softener systems for Ontario’s hard water. Learn how softeners protect your appliances and provide cleaner water for your family.
Plumber using a wrench to tighten a pipe under a bathroom sink.
December 3, 2025
Get your home’s plumbing ready for Christmas and winter guests. Use our expert safety checklist to avoid holiday disasters in Ajax, Whitby and surrounding areas.
Hands using pliers to work on a shiny chrome faucet in a bathroom setting.
November 25, 2025
Hosting this season? Learn how to identify and fix plumbing problems before guests arrive for a stress-free holiday in Oshawa, Pickering, and beyond.
Copper pipes with brass backflow preventer and four yellow-handled ball valves on a gray wall.
November 19, 2025
Understand backflow risks, why prevention matters, and simple ways to safeguard your household water quality across Clarington and the Durham Region.
Hand in yellow glove pouring red liquid from bottle into kitchen sink drain.
November 11, 2025
Debating chemical drain cleaners? Find out the risks, benefits, and safer alternatives for clearing clogs, straight from your trusted Durham Region plumbers.
Frozen metal pipe with a red handle and clamp, likely in a cold environment.
November 5, 2025
Learn expert ways to prevent frozen pipes this winter and keep your Ajax or Whitby home's plumbing safe. Protect your pipes from costly cold weather damage.
A man wearing a hard hat is working on a sliding gate.
October 29, 2025
New homeowner with a septic system? Find out essential information about installation and maintenance to keep your system running optimally.
A plumber is fixing a sink with a wrench.
October 21, 2025
Winter is coming and your plumbing needs preparation. Follow our guide to prepare your pipes and pumps for the cold season to avoid costly repairs.
A man in a blue hard hat is working on a heating system.
October 15, 2025
Discover why regular pump maintenance is crucial for preventing blockages and ensuring the longevity of your home's pumping systems.